What are the unintended consequences of AI?

188th Edition

Which college would Socrates attend?

Lately, there are more articles and essays written about the impact of AI than any other topic. Even more than the current president, if you can believe that. The Wall Street Journal recently published an interesting article by Stephen Lewarne, Professor of Economics and Finance at Franciscan University of Steubenville in Ohio, “Socrates Would Thrive in the Age of AI.”

Mr. Lewarne begins the essay by describing a situation at Brown University in which a professor was concerned about students using AI to cheat on take home exams. Lewarne explains that this is only a symptom and the real challenge is to change the way students are taught. As he states it, “The scarce resource today isn’t information but judgment.” This begs a few interesting questions. First, does the use of AI lead to better judgment? Does instant access to unlimited amounts of data and information lead to wisdom? The author points out that in Socrates’ day, students demonstrated learning through dialogue. People conducted face-to-face conversations and listened intently while arguments were presented and supported. To his credit, Mr. Lewarne is using a similar approach with his students. He states, “Half of each student’s final course grade comes from an individual oral exam conducted without notes, computers or phones. Students must explain their reasoning, defend their conclusions, respond to criticism and demonstrate ownership of what AI helped them produce.”  

This teaching approach reminded me of the most difficult course I took in business school. It was Management Operations. During each class the professor would select a single student to present his strategy and recommendations for the assigned business case. He would then systematically tear apart the student’s argument whenever he saw the opportunity to do so. The first student to endure this humiliating exercise was yours truly. Actually, he selected me for the first two classes. I’ll never forget the sympathetic moan that reverberated softly through the classroom when he called on me for the second time. While the professor easily destroyed my flimsy conclusions, I learned an invaluable lesson – you can never be over prepared.  Or as Josh Merkle, head basketball coach at Randolph Macon teaches his players PITMOV: Preparation is the Mother of Victory.  

Today, we all have access to more information than ever before. Students, business leaders, politicians, and citizens can utilize AI to access all available information about any topic in a matter of seconds. Unfortunately, real time access does not translate into real time understanding. Too often, it does lead to instant opinions, social media posts, and sound bites. For some reason, AI has accelerated the time we take to form conclusions and state opinions. The author states, “The value of a university lies in helping students evaluate evidence, recognize weak reasoning, synthesize competing ideas and defend their conclusions under scrutiny.”   Shouldn’t that be the process every one of us uses all of the time, or at the very least, when we have to make important decisions? 

When was the last time you defended your conclusion under scrutiny or responded to criticism, or synthesized competing ideas? Does anyone ever do that today? Thanks to social media, most of our communication is one way. Now there is nothing wrong with sharing pictures, amusing stories, heartfelt experiences, or other pleasantries on social media. But to form opinions about economic policy, government regulation, and rules for civic society, some level of wisdom and judgment should be utilized. The author’s major point that AI gives us information but not necessarily judgment, is disconcerting, but undeniably true. Wisdom is a prerequisite to prudent judgment and is not instantaneous. It is cultivated over time, incorporating knowledge and experience. There isn’t a short cut, and there need not be. 

Influential leaders, in the public or private sector, should hold themselves to the highest possible standard regarding how they make decisions and communicate opinions and recommendations. When faced with important decisions, or new information about controversial issues, the rest of us might learn new insights if we take a moment to pause, reflect, and listen intently to the other side. More wisdom and judgment will make our world a better place. Add to that a bit more grace and forgiveness and we’d really have something, wouldn’t we?            

Please help me grow my readership by forwarding this to a friend(s). In the meantime, stay tuned for my next newsletter. Thanks

Michael Kayes 

*These views are my personal opinions and are not the viewpoints of any company or organization.

2026 Copyright © Mike Kayes. All rights reserved. | Design by: CCD